Is it possible to assign users/usergroups to certain survey groups to hide survey from certain users?

The GUI seams to allow that, but at least under LS 5.1.15 a test user sees all survey, even when no being assigned to the surveygroup.

 

A surveys group can SHOW some survey, but not hide.

He can add rights only.

Can you give more detail on the user right ?

To see a survey a user can have
- All survey read right
OR
- Surveys in group read right
OR
- Survey read right

DenisChenu wrote:

A surveys group can SHOW some survey, but not hide.
 

Interesting, sounds like I just have the wrong expectation.

Users listed here can see groups in lists, and view group descriptions & settings. This is the minimal permission - you have to use the delete action to remove this permission.This survey group is shown for users with any permission on the survey group, user with any permission on one survey inside this group, or if this group was configured to be available.

The separation of user/usergroup permission settings and surveygroups permission settings seem to add confusion.
Currently the surveygroups are a way to filter a long survey list.

Is it possible to have surveys in a certain surveygroup only shown to certain users/usergroups in LS5?
If not, what is the purpose of the permission settings at all?
 

usersgroup are only a shortcut in Permission management to select all user of group.
Then : i never talk of usersgroup

> Is it possible to have surveys in a certain surveygroup only shown to certain users/usergroups in LS5?

www.limesurvey.org/manual/Survey_group_p...surveys_inside_group

«Permission to access surveys in this group. To see a survey in the list the read/view permission must be given.»
 

> If not, what is the purpose of the permission settings at all?

It's one of the purpose …  i don't understand your questions since all answers are alreay in manual.
If it's unclear : please correct manual.

DenisChenu wrote:

i don't understand your questions since all answers are alreay in manual.
If it's unclear : please correct manual.
 

My post was about if I'm too dumb to get the settings right or I don't get the purpose of the permission assignment.
Or if it is just a function nobody is using and might be broken.

If I add a user/usergroup to a certain surveygroup I would expect that every other user/usergroup NOT assigned to that surveygroup cannot see/view this survey in the backend.
The manual page seems not to contradict that expectation.

 The manual page seems not to contradict that expectation.

Maybe because ALL system in LimeSurvey never remove a right.

If User A see Survey in This group : user A have a right on this survey

It can be Global right or Single Survey right in LimeSurvey 3.X ( 2 way to get right)
It can be Global right, Survey right OR SurveysGroup rights in LimeSurvey 3.X

Please : check how tghis usezr can see this survey : if right didn't come form Surveys group : it comes from Global or Survey.

> Can you give more detail on the user right ?

This question still valid : what is the global right of this user + survey right of this user.

PS : The Survey right must be adapated too. www.limesurvey.org/manual/Survey_permissions
 

jelo wrote:

If I add a user/usergroup to a certain surveygroup I would expect that every other user/usergroup NOT assigned to that surveygroup cannot see/view this survey in the backend.
The manual page seems not to contradict that expectation.
 

Because IT'S the case (except if user have Global surveys right management).
I just check again

1. Create TEST user
2. Create Group1 and Group2
3. Create SurveyG1 and put it in Group1
4. Create SurveyG2 and put it in Group2
5. Give all surveys right to TEST user in Group1
6. Login as test user : see only SurveyG1

DenisChenu wrote:

Maybe because ALL system in LimeSurvey never remove a right.
This question still valid : what is the global right of this user + survey right of this user.
 

Thanks, then it will be the global permissions which are usually set in small setups. They need to be removed to let survey group permissions shine. That seems to work in LS5.
 

I check : if user have ALL survey right set : the indeterminate is show

See issue bugs.limesurvey.org/view.php?id=14558